The Best Bottles for Your Holiday Table (and the Type of Guest Who Pairs With Each)

The holidays are finally here — the season of full tables, clinking glasses, good bourbon, great whiskey, and the people who make it all unforgettable. And if there's one thing we love at Aged in Oak, it's finding the perfect bottle to match the moment (and the personality sitting next to it).
Whether you're hosting a cozy family dinner or a full-scale holiday bash, here’s our guide to the best bottles for your holiday table, plus the type of person who pairs perfectly with each pour.
Blanton’s Single Barrel – The Classic Crowd-Pleaser
A top search every holiday season, Blanton’s is the bottle people bring when they want to impress — smooth, iconic, collectible, and always appreciated.
Pairs perfectly with: The Elegant Guest Who Brings Homemade Pie. They dress well, compliment your tablescape, and somehow make every toast sound profound.
Weller Special Reserve – The Easygoing Holiday Favorite
Affordable, smooth, and beloved—Weller is one of the most searched-for bourbons in the country. It’s the laid-back bottle that settles into the table conversation effortlessly.
Pairs perfectly with: The Guest in a Cozy Sweater Who Brought Thoughtful Gifts. They’re warm, dependable, and always make the night feel relaxed.
Four Roses Small Batch Select – The Romantic Traditionalist
Floral, nuanced, and perfectly balanced — Four Roses is for the guest who appreciates craftsmanship and ritual.
Pairs perfectly with: The Person Who Actually Makes Their Dessert From Scratch. They light the good candles, read tasting notes, and savor every sip.
Penelope Bourbon Architect – The Modern Creative
Penelope Architect is one of our most requested recommendations — contemporary, beautifully layered, and visually stunning.
Pairs perfectly with: The Trendy Friend With Perfectly Wrapped Gifts. Cool, composed, and always in the know.
Peerless Small Batch Bourbon – The Overachiever
Bold and full of flavor, Peerless is for those who love depth and complexity in their holiday pours.
Pairs perfectly with: The Cousin Who Makes an Over-the-Top Side Dish… And It’s Amazing. Not showing off — just naturally exceptional.
Chicken Cock Bourbon – The Life of the Party
Fun, historic, and surprisingly sophisticated — Chicken Cock is the bottle that turns a quiet dinner into a celebration.
Pairs perfectly with: The Extrovert Who Starts the Group Photos. Energy, charisma, and a guaranteed memorable night.
Macallan Rare Cask – The Showstopper Scotch
Refined and unforgettable, Macallan Rare Cask is what you serve when the night calls for something exceptional.
Pairs perfectly with: The Well-Traveled Uncle With a Silk Scarf and Endless Stories. High standards, higher flavor expectations.
More Bottles We’d Love at the Holiday Table
(And the personalities they’d bring with them!)
Old Forester 1910 – The Smooth Talker
Rich, toasty, and universally loved.
Pairs with: The guest who can talk to anyone — including your 92-year-old grandmother.
Elijah Craig Toasted Barrel – The Warm Hug in a Bottle
Toasty, sweet, vanilla-forward —this one feels like sitting by the fire.
Pairs with: The sentimental one who makes everyone go around and share what they’re thankful for.
High West Midwinter Night’s Dram – The Holiday Purist
It’s basically bottled holiday season — spiced, rich, and seasonal.
Pairs with: The guest already wearing festive pajamas on December 1st.
Lagavulin 16 – The Peat Lover’s Dream
Smoky, rich, and perfect for slow sipping after dinner.
Pairs with: The deep thinker who hangs back after dessert for “just one more pour.”
So — Who’s Sitting at Your Holiday Table?
Whether you're shopping for the best holiday bourbon, choosing a whiskey gift for the collector in your life, or curating the perfect lineup for your own table, these bottles bring personality, warmth, and a touch of storytelling to the season.
At Aged in Oak, we’re here to help you find the perfect match — whether you need a showstopper for your bar cart or a crowd-pleaser for Christmas dinner.
Ready to shop? Explore our latest auction, browse the tasting parlor, or send this guide to your bourbon-loving crew and let them pick their holiday-table alter ego.
Cheers to good people, great bottles, and unforgettable holidays.
More Fresh Pours and Perspectives

Winter Warmers: Bourbon Cocktails to Cozy Up Your Holidays

Winter Warmers: Bourbon Cocktails to Cozy Up Your Holidays

Inside the December Auction: Weller Favorites, Rare Scotch Gems & Holiday-Ready Finds

Inside the December Auction: Weller Favorites, Rare Scotch Gems & Holiday-Ready Finds
.jpg)
The Great Whiskey Breakdown: What Separates Scotch from Bourbon (Besides Geography)
.jpg)
The Great Whiskey Breakdown: What Separates Scotch from Bourbon (Besides Geography)

Inside the Auction: Rare Scotch, Collector Trains & 200+ Bottles Ready for the Taking

Inside the Auction: Rare Scotch, Collector Trains & 200+ Bottles Ready for the Taking

The Bourbon Family Tree: Exploring the Branches of America’s Favorite Spirit

The Bourbon Family Tree: Exploring the Branches of America’s Favorite Spirit

From Distillery to Digital — How Bourbon Collecting Moved Online

From Distillery to Digital — How Bourbon Collecting Moved Online

Blanton’s Bourbon: History, Expressions, and the Hype Behind America’s Most Collectible Bourbon

Blanton’s Bourbon: History, Expressions, and the Hype Behind America’s Most Collectible Bourbon

Inside the Auction: Iconic Bottles, Bourbon Legends & the Thrill of the Bid

Inside the Auction: Iconic Bottles, Bourbon Legends & the Thrill of the Bid

Barrel Finishes 101: The Secret Influence of Wood

Barrel Finishes 101: The Secret Influence of Wood

Sip Local: Cedar Ridge Distillery Tasting at Aged in Oak

Sip Local: Cedar Ridge Distillery Tasting at Aged in Oak

Inside the Auction: Powerhouse Picks, Proof, and the Joy of the Bid

Inside the Auction: Powerhouse Picks, Proof, and the Joy of the Bid

The Thrill of No Reserve: Why These Bourbon Auctions Keep Collectors Coming Back

The Thrill of No Reserve: Why These Bourbon Auctions Keep Collectors Coming Back

The Thrill of No Reserve: Why These Bourbon Auctions Keep Collectors Coming Back

The Thrill of No Reserve: Why These Bourbon Auctions Keep Collectors Coming Back

What Bourbon Is Made From: The Art (and Law) Behind America’s Spirit

What Bourbon Is Made From: The Art (and Law) Behind America’s Spirit

The Ghosts of the Rickhouse: Haunted Legends of Bourbon Country

The Ghosts of the Rickhouse: Haunted Legends of Bourbon Country

Single Barrel vs. Small Batch: What’s the Difference (and Does It Matter?)

Single Barrel vs. Small Batch: What’s the Difference (and Does It Matter?)

Bottles with a Past: The Spooky Side of Bourbon History

Bottles with a Past: The Spooky Side of Bourbon History
.jpg)
Inside the Auction: Hidden Gems, Signed Bottles & Kentucky’s Finest
.jpg)
Inside the Auction: Hidden Gems, Signed Bottles & Kentucky’s Finest

The Bourbon Graveyard: Trends That Deserve to Rest in Peace

The Bourbon Graveyard: Trends That Deserve to Rest in Peace

How to Read a Bourbon Label Like a Pro: Decoding the secrets behind age, proof, and distillery details

How to Read a Bourbon Label Like a Pro: Decoding the secrets behind age, proof, and distillery details

Bringing Bourbon’s Heritage Home: How Aged in Oak captures the soul of Bardstown in the heart of Vernon Hills.

Bringing Bourbon’s Heritage Home: How Aged in Oak captures the soul of Bardstown in the heart of Vernon Hills.

Inside the Auction: Bourbon Legends, Cult Favorites, and the Hunt for Purple Reign

Inside the Auction: Bourbon Legends, Cult Favorites, and the Hunt for Purple Reign

The Bourbon Boom That Refused to Bust

The Bourbon Boom That Refused to Bust

Pour Decisions Made Easy: Our Approachable Guide to Bourbon Basics and Bottles Worth Starting With

Pour Decisions Made Easy: Our Approachable Guide to Bourbon Basics and Bottles Worth Starting With

Bourbon, Community, and a Little Rebellion: Why tastings are the hottest social scene of 2025

Bourbon, Community, and a Little Rebellion: Why tastings are the hottest social scene of 2025

The Bottle That Broke the Rules: The Story of Blanton’s Original Single Barrel

The Bottle That Broke the Rules: The Story of Blanton’s Original Single Barrel

A Toast to Hoptoberfest: New Faces, Great Bourbon, and Unforgettable Conversations

A Toast to Hoptoberfest: New Faces, Great Bourbon, and Unforgettable Conversations
.jpg)
Bourbon Through the Ages: The Stories Behind America’s Spirit
.jpg)
Bourbon Through the Ages: The Stories Behind America’s Spirit
.jpg)
Rare Bourbon, Signature Cocktails, and Community -- Find It All At Aged in Oak in Vernon Hills
.jpg)
Rare Bourbon, Signature Cocktails, and Community -- Find It All At Aged in Oak in Vernon Hills

Fall Into Flavor: Bourbon Recipes That Hit Harder Than Pumpkin Spice

Fall Into Flavor: Bourbon Recipes That Hit Harder Than Pumpkin Spice

What Your Go-To Pour Says About You: A Bourbon Personality Test You Didn’t Know You Needed

What Your Go-To Pour Says About You: A Bourbon Personality Test You Didn’t Know You Needed

From Still to Auction Block: How Bourbon Matures (And Why Oak Is Everything)

From Still to Auction Block: How Bourbon Matures (And Why Oak Is Everything)

Weller Bourbon: The People’s Pappy and the Wheated Whiskey That Broke the Market

Weller Bourbon: The People’s Pappy and the Wheated Whiskey That Broke the Market
.jpg)
Crown Jewel Bourbon Bottles: The Ultimate Collectible Whiskey for Serious Collectors
.jpg)
Crown Jewel Bourbon Bottles: The Ultimate Collectible Whiskey for Serious Collectors

How Global Market Trends Are Shaping the Whiskey Collectible Space in 2025

How Global Market Trends Are Shaping the Whiskey Collectible Space in 2025

Bid Boldly. Sip Exceptionally. Dominate the Auction.

Bid Boldly. Sip Exceptionally. Dominate the Auction.
.jpg)
We’re in the Daily Herald: Building a Bourbon Community in Vernon Hills
.jpg)
We’re in the Daily Herald: Building a Bourbon Community in Vernon Hills
.jpg)
From Shelf to Sip: The People Who Keep Bourbon Alive
.jpg)
From Shelf to Sip: The People Who Keep Bourbon Alive

The Hunt for the Holy Grail: Rare Bourbon Bottles That Define Collecting

The Hunt for the Holy Grail: Rare Bourbon Bottles That Define Collecting

Cash Out Without Selling Out: How to Consign Bourbon with Aged in Oak

Cash Out Without Selling Out: How to Consign Bourbon with Aged in Oak

Not Your Grandfather’s Bourbon: The Rise of the Next-Gen Collector

Not Your Grandfather’s Bourbon: The Rise of the Next-Gen Collector

When to Let Go: Knowing It’s Time to Consign Your Bourbon

When to Let Go: Knowing It’s Time to Consign Your Bourbon

The Gospel According to Pappy: Why This Bottle Rules the Bourbon Underworld
