Cash Out Without Selling Out: How to Consign Bourbon with Aged in Oak
You’ve hunted the bottles. You’ve flexed them on the shelf. Maybe you’ve even cracked a few with friends. But now your collection is starting to feel like it’s running the show instead of you. Whether you need space, cash, or just the thrill of the flip — consigning rare bourbon with Aged in Oak is the move.
Forget the shady Facebook groups, Craigslist creeps, and feeling like just another cog in a big machine. At Aged in Oak, we keep the process fast, clean, and airtight—but with a personal touch. No guessing, no ghosting, no fakes. Just straight talk, real service, and the confidence that your bottles are treated like the treasures they are. With us, you’re not another number — you’re part of the story.
The Playbook: How Consignment Actually Works
- Tell Us What You’ve Got
Send photos, details, and condition notes. We don’t need your life story—just enough to know your bottle’s legit. - Get the Truth (a.k.a. Appraisal)
We size up your bottle, check market demand, and give you a number you can actually trust. No smoke, no mirrors. - Ship It or Drop It
Bring it to us in Vernon Hills or ship it insured. Once it’s in our hands, we handle authentication and cataloging. Your bottle gets tagged and guarded like it’s Fort Knox. - The Auction Stage
We build a killer listing — high-res photos, tasting notes, and a spotlight worthy of its liquid legacy. Set a reserve if you want a safety net. - Let the Bidding War Begin
Watch as collectors duke it out. Refresh the screen. Sip something strong. This is where the fun happens. - You Get Paid
After the hammer falls and the buyer settles, you get your payout—minus our cut (5% + $5 per bottle). Simple math.
Why Aged in Oak (and Not Some Random Dude on eBay)
- We Authenticate Everything: No counterfeits, no catfishing. Every bottle is checked and cleared.
- We Bring Serious Buyers: Our auctions attract collectors, not tire-kickers.
- We’re Transparent: Fees upfront, timelines clear, no shady clauses in fine print.
- We’re Built for Collectors: Sell one unicorn or a whole herd—our system can handle it.
Consignor FAQs (Because You’re Already Asking)
Q: What’s the cut?
A: 5% + $5 per bottle. No surprises.
Q: Can I set a reserve?
A: Absolutely. If you don’t want to sell under a certain price, we’ve got you.
Q: How long ‘til it sells?
A: Depends on the auction calendar, but we don't make you wait. Once it’s listed, bottles move.
Q: Do I need to dump a whole collection?
A: Nope. One bottle or fifty — it’s your call.
Q: What if my bottle flops?
A: If it doesn’t hit reserve, you can pull it or relist. Flexibility is baked in.
Pro Tips from Inside the Barrel
- Receipts Matter: Photos, provenance, packaging —this stuff ups your credibility and value.
- Play the Season: Holiday auctions get hungry bidders. Timing is everything.
- Don’t Overshoot: Price it fair, let the bids drive it up. Greed kills auctions.
- Spread the Word: Share your listing. Make it personal — your network may have hidden bidders.
Ready to Move a Bottle?
Your bourbon’s got history. Don’t let it gather dust in the dark. Turn it into cash, into bragging rights, into the next collector’s centerpiece. At Aged in Oak, you’re not tossing bottles into a faceless system — you’re working with real people who know the chase, respect the pour, and treat your collection like it matters (because it does).
List your bottle. Set it free. Get paid.
More Fresh Pours and Perspectives
.jpg)
We’re in the Daily Herald: Building a Bourbon Community in Vernon Hills
Aged in Oak is more than an auction house — it’s a bourbon community in Vernon Hills. Featured in the Daily Herald, we bring together collectors, curious sippers, and cocktail lovers for auctions, tastings, and hands-on experiences. Come for the bourbon, stay for the connections.
We’re in the Daily Herald: Building a Bourbon Community in Vernon Hills
Aged in Oak is more than an auction house — it’s a bourbon community in Vernon Hills. Featured in the Daily Herald, we bring together collectors, curious sippers, and cocktail lovers for auctions, tastings, and hands-on experiences. Come for the bourbon, stay for the connections.
.jpg)
From Shelf to Sip: The People Who Keep Bourbon Alive
Bourbon isn’t just liquid fire — it’s a magnet for hunters, dreamers, adventurers, and anyone who thrives on a good story with every pour. Rare bottles carry history, chaos, and ambition, and the people who collect them are just as vibrant as the spirits they cherish. In the Bourbon Collective, shelves are as varied as personalities, trades are more than transactions, and every pour sparks connection. This isn’t a dusty club of old bottles—it’s a living, breathing culture where the spirit grows, moves, and thrives through the people who share it.
From Shelf to Sip: The People Who Keep Bourbon Alive
Bourbon isn’t just liquid fire — it’s a magnet for hunters, dreamers, adventurers, and anyone who thrives on a good story with every pour. Rare bottles carry history, chaos, and ambition, and the people who collect them are just as vibrant as the spirits they cherish. In the Bourbon Collective, shelves are as varied as personalities, trades are more than transactions, and every pour sparks connection. This isn’t a dusty club of old bottles—it’s a living, breathing culture where the spirit grows, moves, and thrives through the people who share it.
The Hunt for the Holy Grail: Rare Bourbon Bottles That Define Collecting
Some bottles aren’t just bourbon — they’re legends. From Pappy Van Winkle 23 Year and Willett Purple Reign XII to hidden gems like Thirteenth Colony Double Oaked and Knob Creek 18 Year, we break down what makes a bottle collectible and why smart collectors chase both grails and sleepers. Learn the secrets behind rarity, flavor, and hype — and bid boldly to own a piece of whiskey history.
The Hunt for the Holy Grail: Rare Bourbon Bottles That Define Collecting
Some bottles aren’t just bourbon — they’re legends. From Pappy Van Winkle 23 Year and Willett Purple Reign XII to hidden gems like Thirteenth Colony Double Oaked and Knob Creek 18 Year, we break down what makes a bottle collectible and why smart collectors chase both grails and sleepers. Learn the secrets behind rarity, flavor, and hype — and bid boldly to own a piece of whiskey history.
Not Your Grandfather’s Bourbon: The Rise of the Next-Gen Collector
Dust off the stereotypes — today’s bourbon collectors aren’t your grandfather’s club of stuffy enthusiasts. They’re bold, curious, and flipping the bourbon world on its head.
Not Your Grandfather’s Bourbon: The Rise of the Next-Gen Collector
Dust off the stereotypes — today’s bourbon collectors aren’t your grandfather’s club of stuffy enthusiasts. They’re bold, curious, and flipping the bourbon world on its head.
When to Let Go: Knowing It’s Time to Consign Your Bourbon
Your shelves are full, your collection is solid — but sometimes the smartest move is letting a few bottles go. Learn the signs that it’s time to consign, how to maximize value, and why trusting the right auction house can turn prized pours into opportunity.
When to Let Go: Knowing It’s Time to Consign Your Bourbon
Your shelves are full, your collection is solid — but sometimes the smartest move is letting a few bottles go. Learn the signs that it’s time to consign, how to maximize value, and why trusting the right auction house can turn prized pours into opportunity.
The Gospel According to Pappy: Why This Bottle Rules the Bourbon Underworld
From backroom sales pitches to black-market heists, Pappy Van Winkle’s rise is the stuff of bourbon legend. Here’s why this elusive bottle still rules every collector’s wish list.
The Gospel According to Pappy: Why This Bottle Rules the Bourbon Underworld
From backroom sales pitches to black-market heists, Pappy Van Winkle’s rise is the stuff of bourbon legend. Here’s why this elusive bottle still rules every collector’s wish list.
Tapping a Bourbon Barrel with RD1 Distillery
In collaboration with RD1 Distillery, join us for an exclusive behind-the-scenes look at what happens when a collector taps their very own bourbon barrel. From the hiss of the bung to the first fragrant pour, this video captures every moment of anticipation.
Tapping a Bourbon Barrel with RD1 Distillery
In collaboration with RD1 Distillery, join us for an exclusive behind-the-scenes look at what happens when a collector taps their very own bourbon barrel. From the hiss of the bung to the first fragrant pour, this video captures every moment of anticipation.
Crafting the "Circa 1856 Old Fashioned" at Chicken Cock
In this exclusive clip from Chicken Cock’s Bardstown tasting room, Aged in Oak Co-Founder Justin Pantle shows you how to craft a truly historic riff on the Old Fashioned. Gather your rye, light your torch, and join us for a taste of cocktail lore.
Crafting the "Circa 1856 Old Fashioned" at Chicken Cock
In this exclusive clip from Chicken Cock’s Bardstown tasting room, Aged in Oak Co-Founder Justin Pantle shows you how to craft a truly historic riff on the Old Fashioned. Gather your rye, light your torch, and join us for a taste of cocktail lore.
Aged in Oak Debuts Online Bourbon Community May 15, with Auctions and Bottle Appraisals Coming Summer 2025
Built by collectors, for collectors, the launch marks the first phase of a broader rollout, including expert-led appraisals and in-person events.
Aged in Oak Debuts Online Bourbon Community May 15, with Auctions and Bottle Appraisals Coming Summer 2025
Built by collectors, for collectors, the launch marks the first phase of a broader rollout, including expert-led appraisals and in-person events.
